Peer Review Process

EDITORIAL STANDARDS

Promoting academic quality through a fair, unbiased, and transparent review process.

The mission of Strategic Business and Financial Research (SBFR) is to ensure high academic quality through a fair, unbiased, and transparent peer-review process. Manuscripts are assessed for originality, relevance, academic quality, methodological soundness, and their contribution to business and financial research.

REVIEW MODEL

Double-Blind Peer Review

SBFR follows a double-blind peer-review system in which the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to one another during the review process. This approach is intended to support objective manuscript assessment and minimize potential bias.

Every manuscript is first screened by an editor to evaluate its suitability for the journal's scope and its compliance with basic submission requirements. Manuscripts that meet these preliminary criteria are then sent to appropriate reviewers with expertise in the relevant subject area.

Our review principle

Editorial assessment focuses on the quality and scholarly merit of the manuscript rather than the identity or personal background of its authors.

PURPOSE AND STANDARDS

Objectives of Peer Review

Peer review supports the evaluation, improvement, and responsible publication of scholarly research.

01

Academic Rigor

Ensure academic rigor and scholarly quality.

02

Research Integrity

Promote research integrity and publication ethics.

03

Originality and Impact

Evaluate the originality and potential impact of the research.

04

Journal Relevance

Assess the suitability of manuscripts for the journal's focus.

05

Clarity and Readability

Help make manuscripts clearer, more readable, and understandable.

06

Constructive Feedback

Provide authors with constructive criticism to improve their work.

07

Fair Decisions

Support fair, impartial, and evidence-based editorial decisions.

08

Scholarly Development

Encourage continuing research and improvement in scholarship.

ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK

Review Criteria

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts using the following academic and scholarly considerations.

  • Originality and novelty of the research.
  • Appropriateness to the aims and scope of the journal.
  • Quality of the literature review and analysis.
  • Clarity and strength of the research objectives and arguments.
  • Appropriateness of the research methodology for the study.
  • Validity and reliability of data analysis and results.
  • Quality of interpretation and discussion.
  • Relevance and practical or theoretical contribution.
  • Structure, clarity, and quality of writing.
  • Compliance with applicable ethical requirements.
  • Overall contribution to business, finance, management, strategy, economics, or related research.
OUTCOMES OF REVIEW

Editorial Decisions

Editorial decisions are made by considering the reviewers' recommendations together with the editor's independent assessment.

Decision 01

Accept without Revision

The manuscript is accepted in its current form without substantive revisions.

Decision 02

Accept with Minor Revisions

The manuscript may be accepted subject to limited corrections or clarifications.

Decision 03

Major Revisions

Substantial changes are required, and the revised manuscript may undergo further evaluation.

Decision 04

Reject the Manuscript

The manuscript is not accepted for publication when it does not meet the journal's requirements or scholarly standards.

Basis for the Final Decision

The decision to publish is based on the manuscript's academic merit, originality and relevance, the quality of its research methodology, the findings and discussion, and the reviewers' recommendations. The editor considers these factors when determining the appropriate editorial outcome.

OUR COMMITMENT

Integrity, Fairness, and Scholarly Excellence

SBFR strives to maintain confidentiality, fairness, editorial independence, transparency, research integrity, and scholarly excellence throughout the peer-review process.